Hiring a contractor is one of the highest-stakes decisions a homeowner makes. You're inviting someone into your home, handing over a deposit, and trusting them to complete work that directly affects your property value, your safety, and your daily life. When it goes wrong — and it does go wrong — the costs are rarely small.
The FTC estimates that contractor fraud costs American homeowners over $10 billion annually. Most of it starts the same way: a homeowner skips one or two of the steps below because they were in a hurry, or because the contractor seemed trustworthy.
Here is the complete vetting checklist — and the red flags that should end the conversation before a deposit is ever discussed.
Why Hiring is Riskier Than It Looks
The contractor marketplace is uneven. Licensing requirements vary dramatically by state and trade — in some states, anyone can call themselves a general contractor with no license at all. Online review platforms are gamed. Word-of-mouth referrals carry real weight but aren't a substitute for verification.
The homeowner is almost always at an information disadvantage: the contractor knows what the work should cost, how long it should take, and what corners can be cut invisibly. A homeowner who doesn't verify credentials and structure the contract correctly has no leverage when something goes wrong.
The good news: a systematic vetting process eliminates most of the risk. Contractors who intend to do bad work don't survive structured vetting — they move to easier targets.
The 7-Step Contractor Vetting Checklist
- Step 1 — License Verification: Look up the contractor's license on your state contractor licensing board website. Confirm the license is current, active, and covers the specific trade (general, electrical, plumbing, HVAC). An expired or wrong-classification license is a hard stop.
- Step 2 — Insurance Verification: Request a Certificate of Insurance showing general liability (minimum $1M) and workers' compensation. Call the insurance provider directly to verify the policy is active — certificates can be forged. If a worker is injured on your property and the contractor lacks workers' comp, you may be liable.
- Step 3 — References: Ask for three references from projects completed in the last 12 months. Call all three. Ask specifically: did they finish on time, stay on budget, and handle problems professionally? One glowing reference and two non-answers tells you something.
- Step 4 — Written Contract: Every project over $500 should have a signed written contract that includes: full scope of work, materials specified by brand/grade, start date, completion date, payment schedule, and what happens if the scope changes. "We'll figure it out" is not a contract.
- Step 5 — No Full Upfront Payment: Standard payment structure for reputable contractors: 10–25% deposit at signing, progress payments tied to specific milestones, final 10–15% withheld until completion and inspection. Any contractor who demands full payment upfront is a red flag, not a business partner.
- Step 6 — Permit Awareness: Ask whether the project requires permits and who will pull them. Unpermitted work can void your homeowner's insurance, create problems at sale, and leave you liable if something fails. Reputable contractors pull permits as a matter of course and include permit costs in their bid.
- Step 7 — Lien Waiver: When you make each payment, request a signed lien waiver from the contractor and from any subcontractors on the job. Without lien waivers, a supplier or subcontractor the contractor failed to pay can place a lien on your property — even after you paid the contractor in full.
"I skipped the lien waiver step because the contractor seemed like a straight shooter. He was — but he didn't pay his drywall sub. I had a lien on my house for $8,400 I'd already paid. The legal fees to clear it cost another $2,000."
5 Red Flags That Should End the Conversation
- Door-to-door solicitation after a storm. Storm chasers are the most common form of contractor fraud. They appear after hail or wind events, offer to "inspect your roof for free," and push you to sign a contract before your insurance claim is even filed.
- Demands for large cash deposits upfront. Legitimate contractors have supplier accounts and don't need your money to buy materials before the job starts. A demand for 50%+ upfront in cash is a theft pattern, not a business requirement.
- Reluctance to provide references or license number. This is not shyness. Contractors who do good work are proud to provide references. A license number is public information that takes five seconds to share.
- No physical business address. A contractor operating from a P.O. box or who can't tell you where their business is based is harder to pursue legally if something goes wrong. Verify the address is a real location.
- Pressure to decide immediately. "This price is only good today" is a sales tactic designed to prevent you from getting competing bids. Reputable contractors build their schedule — they don't manufacture urgency to skip your vetting process.
How Bid Marketplaces Protect You
One of the most effective structural protections for homeowners is using a managed bid marketplace rather than hiring directly from a referral or directory. A quality marketplace pre-screens contractors for license and insurance before they can bid on jobs, provides standardized scopes of work that make bids directly comparable, and holds funds in escrow until work milestones are verified.
The escrow structure is particularly important. When your payment is held by a neutral third party and released only on milestone completion, the contractor's incentive structure changes entirely. There's no payment to disappear with after the deposit, and no leverage to demand more money mid-job.
Escrow-backed bids eliminate the most common contractor dispute scenario: partial payment, abandoned job, contractor unreachable. No escrow means no enforcement mechanism if things go wrong.
What to Do When Something Goes Wrong
Even with a solid vetting process, disputes happen. If a contractor stops showing up, does substandard work, or refuses to address problems:
- Document everything in writing — photos, dated emails, text messages.
- Send a formal written notice via certified mail giving a specific deadline to remedy the issue.
- File a complaint with your state contractor licensing board — this creates an official record and can affect their license.
- If funds are in escrow, notify the escrow holder immediately and do not authorize release.
- For amounts under $10,000 in most states, small claims court is faster and cheaper than a general civil suit.
Post a Job. Get Vetted Bids.
BOOJEE Maintenance connects homeowners with pre-screened contractors. All bids are standardized, all contractors are license and insurance verified, and all payments are escrow-protected until the work is done.
Post Your Project →See how the escrow process works →